Craig S. Tuttle

Craig has dedicated his entire career to helping people harmed by the negligence of others. At the heart of each case are people, and Craig aggressively advocates against corporations, insurance companies, and medical providers to ensure his clients are not forgotten and that their stories are heard. Craig has extensive experience in all aspects of litigating medical malpractice, legal malpractice, complex personal injury, and wrongful death claims, including frequently litigating cases through a jury trial as lead counsel, throughout Ohio. Craig also has extensive experience in representing clients successfully in mediation, and securing millions of dollars for his cclients through settlements and verdicts. In recognition of his successful efforts on behalf of his clients, Craig has been honored as a Super Lawyer and was granted membership into the Million Dollar Advocates Forum and Multi-Million Dollar Advocates Forum. He is also presently on the Board of the Ohio Association for Justice - a state-wide organization of attorneys fighting for the rights of individuals throughout Ohio - and serves as the Medical Negligence Chair for that organization. Craig's professional experience also includes authoring articles and presenting at numerous legal seminars, as well as previously serving as the President of the Central Ohio Association for Jusstice. Prior to starting his legal career, Craig graduated magna cum laude from Cleveland-Marshall College of Law, where he won awards for Outstanding Appellate and Oral Advocacy, and was honored as a Presidential Management Fellow by the U.S. Government. Outside of the courtroom and legal life, Craig serves his local community by volunteering extensively coaching youth baseball, serving as an advisor and alumni board member for the Alpha Sigma Phi Fraternity at his alma mater, Bowling Green State Unviersity. An Eagle Scout, Craig also gives time as a leader for his son's Scouting America Troop in Hilliard. Awards and Honors Super Lawyers® Selectees Craig S. Tuttle included in a Super Lawyers® list Honors Multi-Million Dollar Advocates Forum, 2025 – Present Million Dollar Advocates Forum, 2021 - Present Super Lawyers List Selectee - 2024-Present National Trial Lawyers Top 100 - 2023 President’s Award, Ohio Association for Justice, 2021 Louisville Slugger Award, Central Ohio Association for Justice, 2018 (presented to attorneys who “knock one out of the park for justice”) President’s Award, Ohio Association for Justice, 2016 Super Lawyers Rising Star Achievement, 2019 - Present Other Sources of Feedback About Craig S. Tuttle Included on the 2026Ohio Super Lawyers list Past Lists 2025 Ohio Super Lawyers list 2024 Ohio Super Lawyers list 2022 Ohio Super Lawyers list 2021 Ohio Super Lawyers list 2020 Ohio Super Lawyers list 2019 Ohio Super Lawyers list

• Partner

• Supreme Court of Ohio
• Ohio
• U.S. District Court Northern District of Ohio
• U.S. District Court Southern District of Ohio

• Ohio Association for Justice (Medical Malpractice Chair, 2022-present)
• Central Ohio Association for Justice (Judicial Screening Committee, 2014-2020)
• Central Ohio Association for Justice (Medical Malpractice Chair, 2015-2020)
• Central Ohio Association for Justice (Past President, 2021-2022)
• American Association for Justice
• Ohio State Bar Association
• Columbus Bar Association (Barrister’s Leadership Program, 2014)